Understanding Horse Behavior and Training Knowledge in Therapeutic Riding
Abstract
Equine-assisted services (EAS), including adaptive and therapeutic riding (AR/TR), have expanded considerably over the past three decades, bringing increased scrutiny to instructor competency, horse welfare, and participant safety. Central to effective practice is the ability to accurately interpret equine behaviour and apply learning theory, skills that extend well beyond traditional riding proficiency. This article reviews a survey-based study of more than 200 therapeutic riding instructors in the United States by Rankins et al. (2025), which assessed participants’ knowledge of horse behaviour and operant conditioning principles. The study revealed a significant gap between instructors’ perceived expertise and their actual performance: only 5% correctly identified all behavioural indicators in video assessment, and fewer than 21% achieved perfect scores on training-related questions. These findings point to systemic deficiencies in how equine behaviour and learning theory are understood and applied in AR/TR contexts, with direct implications for both participant safety and animal welfare. This review examines the study’s key findings, situates them within current research on equine cognition and welfare, and argues for the integration of contemporary behaviour science — including objective assessment tools such as ethograms and the Equine Facial Action Coding System — into instructor training and certification standards.
Introduction
Equine-assisted services (EAS) is a multifaceted umbrella term describing a range of interventions where horses are fundamental to supporting human well-being in physical, cognitive, emotional, and social aspects. Within this broad field, adaptive or therapeutic riding (AR/TR) includes both mounted and unmounted activities, specifically designed to provide therapeutic benefits. These activities are customized to satisfy the unique abilities or disabilities of the individuals involved and are led by specialized instructors, along with activities like groundwork and vaulting, as well as other tasks such as grooming, handling, and just observing. These exercises facilitate the health benefits associated with interacting with equines.
Over the last three decades, human services integrating equines have seen considerable diversification and growth. As these services have expanded, greater attention has been paid to the role of the horse, the competencies of instructors, and the welfare implications of therapeutic practice. In AR/TR settings, instructors require more than technical riding skill. They must also be able to interpret equine behaviour accurately, understand basic learning theory, and make informed decisions that support both participant safety and equine welfare. These concerns sit at the centre of Rankins et al.’s 2025 study on therapeutic riding instructors’ perceptions and knowledge of horse behaviour and training in the United States. This review examines that article’s key findings, relevance, and implications for practice.
The study
To comprehend how these instructors’ competency requirements translate into the professional landscape, it is necessary to examine the existing knowledge base in the field. To do that, a recent survey conducted in the United States evaluated more than 200 therapeutic riding instructors (Rankins et al., 2025). This research aimed to assess instructors’ practical equestrian experience alongside their true understanding of horse behaviour and related learning theory principles.
Distributed through the Professional Association of Therapeutic Horsemanship (PATH) International, the study analyzed 204 fully completed questionnaires to ensure a robust dataset from across the sector. Researchers used statistical methods to investigate the correlation between professional background and the capacity to accurately recognize behavioural cues, definitions of operant conditioning, and practical training situations. The demographic breakdown showed that the vast majority were female (98%) and Caucasian (97%), and held certifications as therapeutic riding instructors (74%). The average age was 50, with participants having roughly 14 years of experience in the AR/TR sector, originating mostly from professional or recreational equestrian backgrounds. As part of the assessment, participants were tasked with pinpointing behavioural patterns in video footage and identifying operant conditioning concepts.
The results revealed a considerable disparity between the instructors’ perceived knowledge and their actual comprehension, particularly in recognizing equine behaviours and applying fundamental training concepts. Despite many instructors possessing decades of hands-on experience, a mere 5% successfully identified all the behavioural indicators in the video clips, and only slightly more than 20% achieved perfect scores on the training-oriented questions. This knowledge gap is concerning since therapy horses operate in close proximity to vulnerable individuals. Misinterpreting the horse’s state or responses could drastically compromise safety. For example, behaviours like “licking and chewing” are frequently misinterpreted as indicators of relaxation within certain training methodologies. These behaviours may occur after a stressful event or as a release from restraint. Likewise, behaviours such as biting or resisting commands may not simply be “refusals,” but could potentially reflect underlying physical pain, discomfort, or confusion from ambiguous cues. Such nuances could be critical: These misjudgments can precipitate dangerous encounters and cause handlers to neglect the animal’s welfare. These behavioural responses are often best understood as possible indicators of deeper issues.
In particular, while highly experienced instructors demonstrated greater proficiency in detecting equine behaviours, they frequently encountered difficulties with theoretical training frameworks, particularly operant conditioning, a foundational element of learning theory (Murphy et al., 2007). The results of this research suggest that practical experience alone is inadequate, and an equally robust foundation in how horses learn is also required. Bridging this gap would reduce inconsistencies in interpreting the horse’s communication, a vital necessity in therapeutic riding, where safety is paramount. In fact, research in this field often highlights a notable disjunction between perceived expertise (confidence) and objective competence. This misunderstanding, where high levels of confidence don’t necessarily correlate with accuracy, is particularly common in fields lacking standardized external metrics, like evaluation of animal behaviour. Ultimately, even veteran practitioners stand to gain from contemporary, scientifically grounded education. Enhancing their grasp of genuine equine behaviour and cognition enables instructors to cultivate safer, more accommodating settings for both the animals and the participants (Seery & Wells, 2024).
Perception and misperception
Most participants in this research exhibited a level of confidence in their horse behavioural knowledge that exceeded their actual test performance, a trend that corresponds to previous research (Rudd et al., 2022). Specific actions, such as biting and nipping, were widely recognized as indicators of stress or compromised welfare, presumably because of their direct correlation with safety hazards and the subsequent removal of horses from EAS duties.
Correctly interpreting the horse’s emotional state and any signs of physical pain or distress, especially concerning riders who distribute their weight asymmetrically in the saddle (Uldahl et al., 2021), is not only important for general human-horse interaction and training; it is especially vital when vulnerable individuals are actively involved, such as in EAS programs. Detecting equine stress signals early serves a dual protective purpose for both the animal and the participant. Firstly, it allows handlers to foresee behaviours resulting from prolonged stress by noticing subtle precursor cues before the horse acts out in a way that causes distress or danger. Secondly, it safeguards the horse by preventing the exacerbation of stress and its resulting behavioural issues. Individuals who lack an understanding of equine behaviour can face notable hazards during these sessions (Merkies et al., 2018). As sensitive prey animals, horses easily become distressed in anxiety-inducing situations, which frequently triggers volatile flight instincts. Such behaviours usually originate from physical pain (like lameness or spinal problems) or from a state of confusion brought on by contradictory commands.
The Rankins et al. (2025) study also noted additional indicators of conflict, including slow or non-existent reactions to the rider, underscoring the negative effects of improperly applied learning theories. A large proportion of the instructors struggled with the principles of operant conditioning, mirroring patterns found in studies of both competitive and recreational equestrian disciplines. Misunderstanding these principles often leads to the improper application of learning theories, which can generate significant conflict for the horse. Beyond the mechanics of training, the inaccurate interpretation of a horse’s emotional state presents a distinct welfare challenge.
They also found that behaviours such as licking and chewing were regularly framed as positive – an interpretation grounded in common belief rather than the behavioural literature. These classification errors point to wider issues, such as a lack of precise vocabulary and core knowledge to describe the range and nuance of equine emotions. Because they are prey animals, horses instinctively tend to hide expressions of vulnerability, such as stress, pain, or weakness. This evolutionary trait makes welfare assessment highly susceptible to subjective biases. For example, research by Smith et al. (2025) focused on horse owners in veterinary settings in the U.K. The authors found that the recognition of equine pain is highly predisposed to subjective biases, often contextualized or dismissed as “fleeting mood swings.”
Consequently, descriptions like “calm” or “quiet” might actually obscure severe underlying welfare issues, such as learned helplessness.
What “science-based” should actually mean for training
EAS programs cannot be directly compared with traditional riding or competitive equestrian sports regarding how the horse is employed. However, EAS activities introduce a multitude of environmental variables, spanning both biomechanical and behavioural aspects, that can generate chronic stress for the horse. Therefore, EAS instructors have to face a complex balancing act: the simultaneous management of the therapy progression, the participant’s needs, and the horse’s physical and emotional state. As the findings from Rankins’s research illustrate, relying on traditional intuition is not sufficient anymore. It is imperative that these professionals receive high-quality education on the latest research concerning equine behaviour, pain manifestation, and stress indicators, learning to decode a horse’s action and recognize when these things are compromised by misleading interpretation, a result of decades of anthropomorphic biases.
Today, even though certain behavioural cues remain subtle and challenging to detect, specific tools exist to facilitate rigorous, scientific observation. Adopting a “science-based” approach means firstly replacing subjective guesswork with objective, measurable data. Modern ethology can provide the necessary tools for rigorous observation. Instruments such as specific ethograms and the Equine Facial Action Coding System offer objective behavioural, postural, and facial metrics that help handlers identify negative emotional states like irritation and stress, and signs of discomfort or pain.
The historical focus on the clinical outcomes of EAS has somewhat overshadowed the reality that therapeutic settings are not neutral environments for the equines involved; these workspaces can impose unique and cognitively demanding pressures on the animals. Therapies are frequently conducted in enclosed arenas and require horses to endure extended handling by unfamiliar people. Therefore, attention to equine welfare in these procedures is of primary importance. Foundational care involves proper horse management, guaranteeing proper nutrition, disease prevention, shelter, and safety, alongside the freedom to move regularly and socialize with other equines. Yet, the very nature of EAS work can still subject the horse to considerable stress. The ability of an instructor to identify the earlier warning signs of mental distress is crucial, not simply to avert safety hazards for the participants, but to actively mitigate and prevent equine suffering.
Fortunately, a paradigm shift is underway. The results presented by the research of Rankins et al. align with the broader ethical shift within the industry. As organizations move toward the issue of targeted guidelines, such as those discussed by Kerulo et al. (2020), there is an increasing obligation for instructors and therapists to actively monitor equines to ensure ethical standards and optimize therapeutic safety.
From an ethological perspective, these results suggest that it’s no longer sufficient to rely on traditional knowledge of horsemanship for any equestrian activity, including EAS instructor certification programs. Instead, the data show the essential need to integrate current behaviour science and the promotion of highly nuanced and context-aware interpretation of equine behaviour. Ultimately, the study of Rankins et al. serves as a diagnostic tool for the EAS sector, identifying the specific gaps in instructor knowledge, and providing empirical evidence to align professional practice with modern animal welfare standards.
Conflict of Interest Statement
The author is a regular contributor to the IAABC Foundation Journal but holds no editorial role and had no involvement in the peer-review or editorial decision making process for this article.
References
IAHAIO. (2021). International guidelines on care, training and welfare requirements for equines in equine-assisted services. https://iahaio.org/iahaio-international-guidelines-on-care-training-and-welfare-requirements-for-equines-in-equine-assisted-services/
Kerulo, G., Kargas, N., Mills, D. S., Law, G., VanFleet, R., Faa-Thompson, T., & Winkle, M. Y. (2020). Animal-assisted interventions: Relationship between standards and qualifications.People and Animals: The International Journal of Research and Practice, 3(1), 4. https://docs.lib.purdue.edu/paij/vol3/iss1/4
Merkies, K., McKechnie, M. J., & Zakrajsek, E. (2018). Behavioural and physiological responses of therapy horses to mentally traumatized humans. Applied Animal Behaviour Science, 205, 61-67. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.applanim.2018.05.019
Murphy, J., & Arkins, S. (2007). Equine learning behaviour. Behavioural processes, 76(1), 1-13. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.beproc.2006.06.009
Rankins, E. M., Reega, S. J., Rudd, C., & Peters, B. C. (2025). Horse behavior and training in adaptive/therapeutic riding: A survey of instructors’ perceptions and knowledge in the United States. Applied Animal Behaviour Science, 282, 106490. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.applanim.2024.106490
Rudd, C., Wheeler, B., Pasiuk, E., & Schroeder, K. (2022). An initial survey of volunteer perceptions of horses in equine-assisted services: Volunteer experiences, training, and educational needs. Journal of equine veterinary science, 117, 104090. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jevs.2022.104090
Seery, R., & Wells, D. (2024). An exploratory study into the backgrounds and perspectives of equine-assisted service practitioners.Animals, 14(2), 347. https://doi.org/10.3390/ani14020347
Smith, R., Perkins, L., Pinchbeck, G., & Ireland, J. (2025). Owners’ everyday interactions with their horse: Pain-related issues and those of veterinary concern. Animal Welfare, 34, e62.https://doi.org/10.1017/awf.2025.10036
Uldahl, M., Christensen, J. W., & Clayton, H. M. (2021). Relationships between the rider’s pelvic mobility and balance on a gymnastic ball with equestrian skills and effects on horse welfare. Animals, 11(2), 453. https://doi.org/10.3390/ani11020453
Wood, W., Alm, K., Benjamin, J., Thomas, L., Anderson, D., Pohl, L., & Kane, M. (2021). Optimal terminology for services in the United States that incorporate horses to benefit people: A consensus document. The Journal of Alternative and Complementary Medicine: Paradigm, Practice, and Policy Advancing Integrative Health, 27(1), 88-95. https://doi.org/10.1089/acm.2020.0415
Mike is an emerging animal behaviorist sitting in Minnesota in the US. He carries an MSc in social science research methods (U. of Kentucky) and brings a passion for understanding how the methods we favor shape the knowledge we privilege. Coming from careers in teaching and non-profit program evaluation, he found companion animal behavior by accident helping anxious feline friends in a unique shelter in Ohio. It is a privilege and a joy to combine these and advance the journal in this exciting time of growth.
Alexandra is a certified dog behavior consultant and holds a PhD in neuroscience. She has spent over a decade in academic research and is author of numerous scientific articles on different aspects of brain development, including olfaction, neurogenesis, and memory formation. Her work as a behavior consultant focuses on creating trusting relationships between humans and their dogs through communication, respect, and science-based knowledge. Alexandra is very dedicated to promoting more science within the dog training world. She supports dog guardians and professionals to build a solid understanding of scientific principles and provides guidance on how to apply these to life with dogs. She runs Canine Mindscape in Alicante, Spain.
I’m an Argentinean-Italian dog trainer and CSAT who spent eight amazing years in Brazil learning and working with dogs. Now based in Europe, I volunteer with the IAABC as a translator and, in my free time, help rehomed dogs settle into their new families. I love bridging languages—and hearts—between people and their dogs.
I’m a translator, editor and journalist, as well as canine educator for children and families, specialized in canine body language. I am part of the IAABC Family since 2019, as Language Director at the IAABC and Translators Team Lead at the IAABC Foundation, at the moment. I volunteer at local shelters and promote bite prevention and animal welfare at schools and events all over my country, Uruguay.
I’m a Chilean veterinarian and certified dog trainer, based in Madrid and working at a veterinary clinic. I’ve been volunteering with the IAABC and the IAABC Foundation for over seven years. In my free time, I help dogs and their guardians strengthen their bond, and I love spending quality time with my own dogs.
Master’s Degree in Natural Sciences, with a strong interest in environmental sustainability and the protection of natural ecosystems. Passionate about writing and science communication, she collaborates with multidisciplinary teams on research projects, such as Equine International, and with non-profit initiatives in the environmental and cultural fields. She is writing for different magazines, including IAABC Foundation. Her major goal is to improve horse’s welfare through behaviour research and empirical practice.
Adrienne Hovey is the copy editor for the IAABC Foundation journal and the owner of
I believe that knowledge from a wide range of disciplines fosters a more empathetic, curious, and engaging world. I am passionate about social, environmental, and minority rights issues (both human and non-human), and this has invariably led me down the road of multi-species anthropology. Perpetually curious about the world we live in, I hope to contribute towards making the world a kinder place for all of us earthlings to live on!
Beckie Wheldon is based in England, UK, and has been supporting the IAABC Foundation Journal team as a volunteer journal content editor since early 2025. She has a BSc (Hons) Animal Behaviour and Welfare, and has recently completed a MSc Clinical Animal Behaviour. With a passion for both practical and theory, Beckie is proud to be a part of the journal submission journey and support the process of applied animal behaviour information and research getting from our writers to the readers. As her full-time career, Beckie is currently part of the UK veterinary charity, PDSA, as a Learning and Development Business Partner for Veterinary, where she supports the professional development of people in their Veterinary Hospitals. Her last position was with the rescue charity, Dogs Trust, as a Canine Behavioural Welfare Manager, where she worked on embedding evidence-based behavioural welfare best practices throughout policy and practices, with both internal and external professional stakeholders, such as the police and military. With a varied background in kennels, caregiver education, and charity dog training classes, Beckie is also an accredited Animal Training Instructor (APDT UK) and an Associate Clinical Animal Behaviourist (APBC).
Erin Jones, PhD, IAABC-ADT, CDBC, CPDT-KA, CANZ-ATI, CANZ-ABC, is the Journal Director of the IAABC Foundation Journal. She holds a PhD in Human–Animal Studies, an MSc in Anthrozoology, a PG Dip in Animal Welfare, and a BSc (Hons) in Anthropology and Psychology. An international presenter, editor, writer and mentor, Erin’s writing bridges research and practice with a focus on the intersection of philosophy, ethics and dog-centered behaviour practice. She is the author of Constructing Canine Consent and co-editor of Topics in Non/Human Coexistence and numerous academic and trade journal publications.